RAPID CITY - Hani Shafai says he
slept well Monday night after releasing some built-up frustration
over the criticism his proposed multi-use downtown building project
has received.
Shafai, president of Dream Design,
told the Rapid City Council at the start of Monday's council
meeting that he refused to put up with further disparaging remarks
about himself and his company so he decided to withdraw his
proposal.
But after having some time to cool
off, Shafai indicated Tuesday morning that stopping the project is
not as cut and dried as he indicated the night before.
"We're not actually pulling out
completely," he said.
Shafai said he still might walk
away from the project, but first, he wants to have a public hearing
after the June 5 city election.
Shafai wants to use the public
hearing to fully explain the goals of the project, how it is being
funded and to address questions. By having it after the election,
he hopes it will eliminate some political posturing.
"If there is community support, we
will proceed to the next phase. If there is no community support,
we will stop there and shelve the plans, and hopefully someday,
somebody will come along and want to do it," he said.
Shafai is frustrated that the
project, a 15-story, mixed-use building of condominiums, offices,
specialty retail shops and multiple levels of parking on a
city-owned lot on St. Joseph Street, has become a political
football during this year's municipal election campaign.
"It's actually been the coverage
that it's been getting. It became more personal attacks," Shafai
said. "I'm not running for public office, I'm just trying to help.
If I was running for public office, everybody has a right to
criticize me."
Criticism of any project is
expected, Shafai said, but not to the extent he has had on this
one. Particularly galling are claims that he is just a rich
developer trying to get even richer, he said.
"The goal of the project is not to
hurt the community or take advantage of the community; it's to help
the community. It's turning into a project that has been the focus
of the entire political campaign, even though there are more
pressing issues for the city," he said.
But it's not worth doing if there
is no community support, Shafai said.
Shafai said one of the best
designers of mixed-use facilities in the world has been hired to
design the building. Complete design of the project could cost
about $2.1 million, but it will be done in phases.
The first two design phases will
focus on blending the project's goals with downtown. A $150,000
contract has been signed for that phase, which will proceed.
"That phase will give us ideas
about how the building will fit with the downtown," Shafai said.
"My goal is, after the election, to go through a public-hearing
process in which we can get input from people in the community,
regardless if it is positive or negative."
Shafai said he has been shocked
over the tone of some columns and letters to newspapers about the
project, especially because most of those who have written negative
things have not called to ask questions.
Alderman Bill Okrepkie hopes
Shafai can be persuaded to change his mind. He also wants critics
to come forward with their plan to move the city forward.
"What's your plan? What's your
vision for the community?" Okrepkie asked. "We had a beautiful
project going, one that would have been very beneficial for the
downtown area, and now, we have a strong potential to lose
it."
The project was one of four
proposals received by the city at the end of 2006 and was the top
project reviewed by members of the parking subcommittee of the City
Center Revitalization Task Force.
Last year, city officials asked
for proposals to build more parking, retail and living spaces
downtown. Instead of using $2.8 million in 2012 money designated
for a parking ramp, city officials wanted to create a
public-private partnership that would combine public and private
dollars to build something grander on a city-owned lot
downtown.
The city would provide up to $2.8
million from 2012 funds for the project, and officials have been
discussing the possibility of selling the land on St. Joseph Street
between Fifth and Sixth streets to Shafai.
The city council earlier approved
a tax increment financing district to pay for nearly $12 million in
public improvements associated with the project, including public
parking, burying power lines in the alley and removing contaminated
soil from underground fuel tanks.
The TIF would be used to get a
loan for the improvements, and to pay back the loan plus interest
over the next 20 years.
The rest of the financing for the
$48 million project would come from private investors.
Shafai said financing for the
project is solid. Even after his comments Monday, Shafai said his
investors still want the project to proceed.
"You tell people what it is, and
they get excited about it. The funding is secure. Financing is not
an issue," he said.
Mayor Jim Shaw said Monday night
that ending the project "just takes the wind out of our sails" for
downtown revitalization. He said the project has been explained,
yet people continue to use "mistruths and half truths" to derail
it.
"He's trying to do something good
for the community that essentially we asked him to do, and he's
being bashed for it, over and over," Shaw said. "Why? Apparently
for political gain. I can't think of any other reason."
Contact Scott Aust at 394-8415,
or scott.aust@rapidcityjournal.com