PIERRE - The owner of a Pierre game-processing shop who
accused a federal agent of framing him was fined $2,100 on Friday
for a federal conviction of possessing untagged geese.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Mark Moreno of Pierre said there is no
need for Caleb Gilkerson to spend time behind bars, particularly
since his conviction for violating the Migratory Bird Treaty Act
amounted to a petty offense under federal law.
"It's not the crime of the century," he said, noting the
maximum allowable sentence would be six months in jail and a fine
of up to $5,000.
But the magistrate also pointed out that the $2,100 fine he
imposed is the same that embattled U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
agent Bob Prieksat sought to get Gilkerson to pay when the agent
first ticketed him in December.
Gilkerson, who was among a group who sought unsuccessfully to
have Prieksat fired or transferred, instead insisted he was
innocent and went to trial.
Gilkerson said Friday he intends to appeal his conviction and
sentence, which includes six months probation. He said he will pay
the fine within a week.
Moreno presided over Gilkerson's one-day trial in May and
found him guilty. The fine amounts to $75 for 28 untagged geese,
the magistrate said.
Prieksat testified during the trial that he found untagged
geese in Gilkerson's game-processing business in December, and a
state game warden agreed. Prieksat said those tags are required to
identify which hunters have shot birds and whether they have
exceeded the bag limit.
Gilkerson testified that he believed Prieksat framed him by
removing tags from some geese the agent found in the freezer at
Steamboat Game and Fish, which processes wild game and offers guide
services for hunting, fishing, kayaking and scuba and skin
diving.
Gov. Mike Rounds had asked the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
to fire Prieksat or transfer him because the governor believed
Prieksat had been too aggressive and rude in checking whether
hunters were complying with the law. An agreement reached in June
allows Prieksat to continue supervisory work, but he will no longer
work as a field agent except in emergencies or when directed by his
supervisors on federal or tribal land.
During Friday's sentencing hearing, Assistant U.S. Attorney
Mikal Hanson said Gilkerson's friends consider him a good,
hardworking person, and his crime is not nearly as serious as the
violent offenses frequently handled in federal court.
However, Hanson said he is upset Gilkerson based his defense
on a false claim of being framed. Gilkerson should have followed
his defense lawyer's arguments that technical difficulties make it
hard to comply with the law, Hanson said.
"Instead, he concocted a story about being framed by Officer
Prieksat," Hanson said.
Gilkerson might have become caught up in the emotions of the
crowd of people who were out to get Prieksat, the prosecutor said.
"He just lost sight of the importance of what coming into court and
telling the truth meant," Hanson said.
But defense lawyer Wade Reimers of Pierre said there was
evidence on both sides of the dispute, and some other trial
witnesses supported Gilkerson's version of events.
"He went up there and told it like he thought it happened,"
Reimers said. "He stood up for what he thought was right."