HomeNewsLocal

Prosecutor says Stanton Day a risk to the community

Months after being arrested, bus driver remains in jail without bond

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

buy this photo Former Sturgis school bus driver Stanton Day walks in shackles from jail to the Meade County Courthouse in March. Day was arraigned on seven counts of rape involving school girls months ago, but bond has still not been set for the man who has no previous convictions and strong ties to the Meade County area. (Journal file photo by Dick Kettlewell, Journal staff)

While other South Dakotans charged with sex crimes against children are free on bond, the Meade County school bus driver accused of molesting a 10-year-old girl is going on his fourth month in jail, still with no bond set in his case.
Stanton Day, 65, of Summerset has been in custody since early March when he was arrested and charged with six counts of first-degree rape and one count of sexual contact with a child younger than 16. He faces up to life in prison if convicted.
Fourth Circuit Judge Warren Johnson has denied requests by Steve Christensen, Day's attorney, to set bond in the case.
"We intend to bring this back to the court's attention at the next hearing," Christensen said.
Bond has been set for those charged in several recent cases involving similar crimes not long after those people were taken into custody.
At Day's last court hearing, Christensen brought up the case of Ted Klaudt, 49, the former state representative from Walker charged in two counties with several counts of having sexual contact with two girls.
In Corson County, Klaudt was given a personal recognizance bond, meaning he was freed without having to pay, and in Hughes County, his bond was set at $100,000 cash or surety.
George Krenz, 30, the Hot Springs teacher charged in May with furnishing alcohol to several students and having sex with some of them, is free on a $500 bond.
Kasey Onken, 34, of Rapid City, a man charged five counts of criminal pedophilia for allegedly raping a young girl, is free on a $50,000 bond.
Thomas Muhm, 41, a Rapid City man recently convicted by a jury of raping two young boys, was in jail on a $500,000 bond before his conviction.
Meade County State's Attorney Jesse Sondreal said it is wrong to compare one case to another because there are so many different factors.
"Every case is different, every judge is different, and every defendant and prosecutor is different," Sondreal said.
He said the reason he has asked Johnson not to set bond in the case is that Day continues to pose a risk to the community.
"I don't think it's fair to weigh other cases against this case," Sondreal said. "We feel that this is an appropriate bond based on the facts of the case."
Seventh Circuit Judge Jeff Davis, who is not involved in the Day case and did not comment on it specifically, said the main purpose of bond is ensuring that a defendant appears at all court proceedings.
"Bond can't be used in a punitive manner," Davis said. That law is based on the assumption that all people are innocent until proven guilty either by being convicted by a jury or by pleading guilty.
State law says factors to be considered by a judge setting bond are the nature and circumstances of the offense charged, the weight of the evidence against the defendant, the defendant's family ties, employment, financial resources, character and mental condition as well as his residence in the community, his record of convictions and his record of appearance at court hearings. Also taken into consideration is the risk that the defendant will flee or pose a danger to any person or the community.
Day has no criminal background and has strong ties to Meade County. He was born and raised in the area. He and his wife own a house in Summerset.
So Day may have no criminal history and may have strong ties to the area that might ensure his court appearances, but Sondreal said there is one main reason Day is still in custody.
"He's a threat to the community," Sondreal said. That is why he has continued to ask Johnson not to set bond for Day when the issue is brought up in court.
Christensen said he will renew his request for bond to be set for Day at Day's next hearing July 9 in Sturgis.
In addition to setting a bond, judges usually put certain case-specific bond conditions into place.
Those often include that the person must obey all laws, not have contact with any alleged victims in the case, make all court appearances and not leave the jurisdiction.
"A judge can set bond on all available information including hearsay, things that normally would not be able to be used at trial," Davis said.
He said judicial training courses are offered that discuss criminal procedure and the aspect of bond.
"We just have to do what we think will guarantee court appearances," he said.
In addition to setting a bond, judges usually put certain case-specific bond conditions into place.
Those often include that the person must obey all laws, not have contact with any alleged victims in the case, make all court appearances and not leave the jurisdiction.
If the crime involved alcohol use, bond conditions may require the defendant to refrain from using alcohol and participate in the 24/7 sobriety program.
"You tailor it to the nature of the offense and the individual," Davis said.
He said no bond is generally set for the most serious of offenses.
"Setting no bond is still a bond," he said. "It means you're on the high end of those statutory conditions and have failed almost all categories."
Davis said he reviews all files in a case before a bond hearing where the prosecution and the defense state what they believe bond should be set at.
Judges differ on how they set bond just like they differ in other aspects such as sentencing.
"You bring the whole picture together and try to determine what will guarantee the appearance," Davis said.
Contact Katie Brown at 394-8318 or katie.brown@rapidcityjournal.com

Print Email

/news/local
 
Sponsored by:

Connect with Us