the Journal Editorial Board | Posted: Wednesday, October 15, 2008 11:00 pm
|
Any time there's an accident
involving a school bus, we all take notice.
Unfortunately, another school bus
accident took place recently. We were glad to report that only
minor injuries were received by five of the elementary students.
That's five too many, of course, but considering the bus was
rear-ended by a pickup truck, the toll could have been higher and
much more serious.
A separate incident involving a
school bus took place earlier this month when a bus parked at an
intersection was broad-sided when a driver ran through a stop
sign.
Incidents such as that, and many
much worse, have led to a new rule imposed by the federal
government that requires lap-and-should seat belts for new buses
(that are currently required to have lap belts) weighing less than
5 tons. The new rule also requires larger buses to have higher seat
backs, for safety reasons, than they currently do.
These new rules make good sense
and are reasonable measures to add to the safety of children riding
in buses.
Lt. James Johns of the Rapid City
Police Department did point out that seat belts on the school bus
would likely not have prevented the injuries sustained
Thursday.
"Those big buses, they don't
give," Johns said, explaining how the injuries were likely avoided
and why the bus had minor damage while the other vehicle was
totaled.
Buses are big and intentionally
painted bright colors. You should have trouble spotting one on the
road. But for the smaller buses, the ones under 5 tons addressed in
the new rules, we do see some wisdom in the new rules that have
been applied.
Quite simply, anything within
reason we can do to protect our children should be done.
There were concerns, of course,
with the new rule for bus safety and where it might lead - meaning
to larger buses.
One concern was, if seat belts
were required, how would school districts enforce the rules?
Another was a concern about quick evacuation should dozens of
students be buckled in. And seating capacity would be lost, of
course, should every student be forced to a specific spot, unable
to slide over.
We understand these concerns but
if, after thoughtful discussion and study, it was determined
reasonable steps could increase students' safety, then those steps
would make sense. That doesn't appear to be the case now.
It's easy to say every school bus
should be equipped with the latest safety gear, despite the costs,
and most anxious parents probably have said just that.
But it's not realistic.
Bus crashes are uncommon as are
serious injuries as a result of them. The Transportation Department
shows that 25 million children each year travel on one of 474,000
school buses. And during the course of each year, six children are
killed in school bus accidents
We are glad to see the safety
requirements for smaller buses and the seat modifications for the
larger ones. Both of those moves make good sense.